Should You Reglaze or Replace Your Bathtub? Here’s What You Need to Know

You’re ready to update your bathroom, and your old tub is looking worn out. Scratches, stains, and years of use have taken their toll, and now you're faced with a decision—should you reglaze your bathtub or replace it entirely? Reglazing might seem like a cost-effective shortcut, but is it truly the best option for your home?

We understand that remodeling decisions can feel overwhelming. You want a beautiful, functional bathroom without unnecessary hassle or expense. This option is a consideration for those looking to refresh their bathtub’s appearance without undergoing a full remodel.

At Joyce Windows, Sunrooms & Baths, we have been helping and educating homeowners just like you on bathtub solutions that enhance your home. We offer bathtub replacement, which can offer long-term beauty, comfort, and functionality.

Both options have their advantages, and the right choice depends on your budget, long-term goals, and how you use your bathtub. Understanding the pros and cons of each can help you make the best decision for your home.

What is tub reglazing?

Bathtub reglazing is a process in which the current tub in your bathroom will be stripped of its old finish, any cracks or damage will be repaired, and then a primer, a new surface, and lastly a top coat will be applied. This reglazing process can last anywhere from two to four days before the tub is ready for use. It is highly recommended to be completed by professionals as attempting to DIY your tub resurfacing could end badly with all the steps and time it takes to do the work. Some common risks are bubbling, cracking, chipping, and peeling. All of which need to be addressed to enjoy your tub.

Additionally, because of the chemicals used in this process, you'll want to be cautious doing the work yourself. The fumes produced by the various epoxies and chemicals are not only bad for you, but also for your family. Having professionals do the job means they will be able to deal with the smell and properly ventilate the space. 

Benefits of Reglazing:

✔ Cost-Effective – Reglazing is typically more affordable than a full replacement.

✔ Quick Turnaround – The process takes only a few days, so you’ll have your tub back in use sooner.

✔ Minimal Construction – Since you're keeping the existing tub, there's no need for demolition or major changes to your bathroom.

Things to Consider with Tub Reglazing:

✔ Reglazing is a temporary fix, usually lasting 3-5 years before the surface may start peeling or chipping.

✔ Special care is required—certain cleaners, bathmats, and prolonged moisture can damage the finish.

✔ Strong chemicals are used in the process, so proper ventilation and professional application are recommended.

Bathtub Replacement

A bathtub replacement involves removing your existing tub and installing a brand-new one. Unlike reglazing, which simply resurfaces your old tub, replacement allows you to upgrade your bathtub's style, size, material, and features to better suit your needs.

The process for bathtub replacement involves three steps. First, removal of the old tub. Second, preparation for the new tub. Inspect plumbing connections and make any necessary adjustments for framing or supports for the new tub. Third, install the new tub. Securely placing, sealing, and connecting your plumbing system to ensure proper drainage and water flow. An optional last step is to add finishing touches such as a new wall surround or tiling. 

Depending on the complexity of the project, a bathtub replacement typically takes a day or more to complete, especially if additional work like tile replacement or plumbing adjustments is needed.

Benefits of Tub Replacement:

✔ Long-Lasting Solution – A new tub can last decades with minimal maintenance.

✔ More Options – Choose a deeper tub, a modern style, or even a walk-in shower for added accessibility.

✔ No Special Care Required – Unlike reglazing, you won’t have to worry about peeling, cracking, or avoiding certain cleaning products.

Things to Consider with Tub Replacement:

✔ Higher Initial Cost – A full replacement is a larger investment upfront.

✔ Potential for Structural Adjustments – If changing tub styles, plumbing or space modifications may be needed.

Is Reglazing or Replacement Best for You?

When remodeling a bathroom, it's important to consider all the factors. You want to make sure to make the best decision for your needs and your space. If you're looking for a quick refresh at a lower cost, reglazing can bring new life to your existing tub. If you're planning a full remodel or want a long-term upgrade, replacing your bathtub may be the better investment.

If you're ready to explore your replacement options, Joyce Windows, Sunrooms & Baths can help you find the perfect tub for your bathroom. By replacing your bathtub, you're not just getting a new bathtub—you're investing in a more functional, beautiful, and long-lasting bathroom. 

Explore your options today with a free design consultation with one of our bath experts.